2025 Goat Milk Club
Keep your fridge stocked with delicious and nutritious goat milk
Isn’t it a drag to open the fridge and see that you are almost out of goat milk?
Ever come to the market only to find out we just sold our last bottle?
The 2025 Goat Milk Club is your solution!
We farm in harmony with nature, so our supply of goat milk is naturally limited. Our lady goats take maternity leave in late December, which means we don’t have any goat milk until spring. During this precious dairy season, we can help you have a reliable supply of goat milk!
Join to guarantee that your fridge is stocked with the goat milk you know and love from May through November 2025.
Join the Goat Milk Club today!
Click on the number of bottles below to sign up
What is the Goat Milk Club?
Think of a wine club, but for goat milk! We’ll automatically place your weekly order for delicious and nutrition goat milk. Our subscription starts May 23 and ends November 23. That’s 26 weeks where you don’t have to worry about ordering milk! We’ll do it for you.
Signing up is really easy.
- First, you choose your weekly quantity-1, 2, 3, 4 or 5 quart (32 oz) bottles of goat milk.
- Then, you get to choose your pick up location- any of our 4 farmers markets or our farm store.
- Choose to pay monthly or pay in-full at check out. All payments are made via credit card. Sorry, we can’t take cash or venmo for the subscription.
- Just show up during market or farm store hours and we’ll have your milk ready for pick up.
- Enjoy your freshly bottled goat milk!
If you are out of town and need to skip a week, you can pause your order for the week and we’ll provide you a farm credit. That way you can purchase something else when you return.
You can choose to be billed on a monthly basis, so you pay a little bit throughout the season.
Pick up locations:
Farm Store: 71 Featherbed Ln, Stockton NJ 08559, Fri 3-5pm, Sat 11am-4pm, Sun 11am-4pm
West Windsor Farmer’s Market: Saturdays 9am-1pm
Madison Farmer’s Market: Saturdays 9am-2pm
Hunterdon Community Farmer’s Market: Sundays 9am-1pm
Somerset County Regional Farmer’s Market: Sundays 10am-1pm
Why Goat Milk?
Goat milk is a natural source of vitamins, minerals, proteins, and health-promoting fatty acids. It is easier to digest than cow’s milk. If you have a cow’s milk sensitivity, goat milk may be your answer!
When you enjoy goat milk from Gorgeous Goat Creamery, you are enjoying the ONLY goat milk bottled in New Jersey. We bottle the milk right on our regenerative farmstead, so its fresh, delicious, and all natural. The milk is so fresh, it doesn’t have the characteristic “goaty” flavor. It tastes like creamy, delicious milk. Amazing! Goat milk without the “goatiness”!
Our milk is gently pasteurized to retain all of the key nutrients and minimize any harmful microbes. This is the most gentle pasteurization allowed by law, which means our goat milk is safe to consume for pregnant women, young children and people with health concerns.
All of our milk is packaged in glass bottles. Not only does this improve the flavor of the goat milk, but it also reduces waste. We wash, sanitize and reuse all of the bottles you return to us.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Can I purchase additional milk at the market?
- Yes! We always have milk to purchase when the market starts. However, we may sell out. We cannot hold bottles of milk. You can order extra milk online by Thursday night HERE.
- How do I inform you that I need to skip a week?
- Log in to our online ordering system and select “Skip Week”. You get 4 skip weeks for the season. We’ll release the inventory so someone else can buy your milk and we’ll give you a farm credit to spend another time.
- What if I decide I want fewer or more bottles of milk during the season?
- Please contact us directly via email or chat at the market. This change needs to be done manually by one of our staff members.
